National Survey on Clinical Pharmacy Services of Tertiary Hospitals in China: Part 3. Status Quo of Clinical Pharmacy Service Provision
CUI Li1, XI Xiao-yu2, YAO Dong-ning3, HUANG Yuan-kai2, WANG Yi-tao3, YAO Wen-bing2*
1. Shanghai General Hospital, Shanghai 200080, China; 2. National Development Research Center of Licensed Pharmacist, China Pharmaceutical University, Nanjing 210009, China; 3. Institute of Chinese Medical Sciences, University of Macau, Macau SAR 999078, China
Abstract��OBJECTIVE To obtain data related to status quo of clinical pharmacy service provision of tertiary hospitals, find problems in clinical pharmacy service provision, based on which provide advice on policy formulation. METHODS A face-to-face interview survey was conducted to collect data on status quo of clinical pharmacy service provision of Tertiary hospitals which were analyzed with descriptive statistics tools. RESULTS The proportions of clinical pharmacy related workload to 86.4% of the clinical pharmacists are larger than 40%; relatively more clinical pharmacists focus their work on prescription checking(25.9%), therapeutic regimen(17.3%) or pharmaceutical ward round(15.7%) than other services; medical documentation(53.6%), group consultation(51.7%) and drug abuse prevention(27.3%) are less performed by clinical pharmacists than other duties; 96.9% of the physicians recognized the clinical value of clinical pharmacists�� work, and 97.1% of the physicians adopted the clinical pharmacist��s advices; medical history checking, medication guidance, medication counseling and pharmaceutical ward round are with relatively high coverage(75.3%, 78.0%, 76.2%, and 73.5%) and satisfaction(77.8%, 81.3%, 79.2%, and 76.1%) among the patients. CONCLUSION The construction of clinical pharmacy service system in tertiary hospitals in our country is beginning to obtain achievement.
����,ϯ����,Ҧ����,��Ԫ��,��һ��,Ҧ�ı�. �ҹ�����ҽԺ�ٴ�ҩѧ������״�������о�:(��)�ٴ�ҩѧ����չ��״����[J]. �й�ҩѧ��־, 2018, 53(10): 837-842.
CUI Li, XI Xiao-yu, YAO Dong-ning, HUANG Yuan-kai, WANG Yi-tao, YAO Wen-bing. National Survey on Clinical Pharmacy Services of Tertiary Hospitals in China: Part 3. Status Quo of Clinical Pharmacy Service Provision. Chinese Pharmaceutical Journal, 2018, 53(10): 837-842.
ASHP guidelines on a standardized method for pharmaceutical care. AJHP, 1996, 53(14):1713-1716.
AMERICAN COLLEGE OF CLINICAL P. Standards of practice for clinical pharmacists. Pharmacotherapy, 2014, 34(8):794-797.
SHAO H. A preliminary study on the cultivation mode of american clinical pharmacists. Chin J New Drug(�й���ҩ��־), 2008, 17(1):79-82.
ZHONG Z H, LIU X. Clinical pharmacy in China: yesterday, today, and tomorrow. China Prescr Drug(�й�����ҩ), 2009, 82(4):22-25.
LI K J, HUANG J, CUI L. Investigation on the requirement of pharmaceutical care and work mode of clinical pharmacist. J China Pharm(�й�ҩ��), 2010, 21(18):1722-1724.
LONG M, YAO D J, LI C F. Research on training clinical pharmacist team and optimizing clinical pharmacist service mode. Med Innov China(�й�ҽѧ����), 2012, 9(27):79-80.
ZHANG G L, LUO Y M, DONG Z Q, et al. Rational drug use-the core responsibilities of pharmacists under the new mode of pharmaceutical service. Pharm Clin Res(ҩѧ���ٴ��о�), 2014, 22(6):569-571.
WANG B Y, WANG S Y. Investigation and analysis of the the working status and importance of clinical pharmacy in some hospitals in Chengdu. Chin Pharm Aff(�й�ҩ��), 2016, 30(12):1250-1255.
XING Y, LI X. Investigation and analysis on current situation of implementation of clinical pharmacy among tertiary polyclinics. Acta Univ Med Nanjing(Soc Sci)(�Ͼ�ҽ�ƴ�ѧѧ��:����ѧ��), 2016, 16(1):10-14.
HU M�� JIANG X H�� WU Y P�� et al . Survey on hospital pharmaceutical care in China and the status quo of clinical pharmacy practice(part 2)��survey on status quo of clinical pharmacy practice[J]. J China Pharm (�й�ҩ��)�� 2009�� 20(13)��1030-1032.
ZILLICH A J�� MCDONOUGH R P�� CARTER B L�� et al . Influential characteristics of physician/pharmacist collaborative relationships[J]. Annals Pharmacother �� 2004�� 38(5)��764-770.
MAKOWSKY M J�� MADILL H M�� SCHINDEL T J�� et al . Physician perspectives on collaborative working relationships with team-based hospital pharmacists in the inpatient medicine setting[J]. Int J Pharm Pract �� 2013�� 21(2)��123-127.
ERAH P O�� CHUKS-EBOKA N A Patients�� perception of the benefits of pharmaceutical care services in the management of hypertension in a tertiary health care facility in benin city[J]. Trop J Pharm Res �� 2008�� 7(1)��897-905.
ABEBE T B�� ERKU D A�� GEBRESILLASSIE B M�� et al . Expectation and satisfaction of HIV/AIDS patients toward the pharmaceutical care provided at Gondar University Referral Hospital�� northwestern Ethiopia�� a cross-sectional study[J]. Patient Prefer Adherence �� 2016�� 10�� 2073-2082.
MINARIKOVA D Level and factors influencing the patient��s satisfaction with the pharmaceutical care in Slovakia[J]. Ceska Slov Farm �� 2015�� 64(5)��178-183.
JI C�� LIN Y Investigation on satisfaction of patients with clinical pharmacy service provided by clinical pharmacists[J]. Chin J Hosp Pharm (�й�ҽԺҩѧ��־)�� 2012�� 32(19)��1575-1576.
LI X P�� SHAO H�� YANG S�� et al . Satisfaction survey of patients received clinical pharmacy service in 22 hospitals of Beijing[J]. J Pharm Prac (ҩѧʵ����־)�� 2008�� 26(5)��378-381.
XI X Y�� YAO D N�� HUANG Y K�� et al . National survey on clinical pharmacy services of tertiary hospitals in china�� part 1 introduction of survey and basic conditions of clinical pharmacy service provision[J]. Chin Pharm J (�й�ҩѧ��־)��2017��52(19)��1746-1752.
LIU C�� SHANG E N�� SHAO Z G�� et al . Preliminary exploration into the service mode of clinical pharmacists in the UK hospita[J]. Pharm Care Res (ҩѧ�������о�)�� 2015�� 15(5)��347-350.
ZHU Z�� SHANG N An overview of process change of pharmaceutical care in United States[J]. China Pharm (�й�ҩʦ)��2015�� 18(9)��1571-1573.
QU J�� LIU G F�� ZHU Z�� et al . Construction and development of hospital pharmacy discipline(part i)[J]. Chin J Hosp Pharm (�й�ҽԺҩѧ��־)�� 2014�� 34(15)��1237-1246.
LI X�� HUO H�� KONG W�� et al . Physicians�� perceptions and attitudes toward clinical pharmacy services in urban general hospitals in China[J]. Int J Clin Pharm �� 2014�� 36(2)��443-450.
HU M�� ZHANG L L�� JIANG X H�� et al . Survey on hospital pharmaceutical care in China and the status quo of clinical pharmacy practice(part 3)��survey on attitudes of personnels related to clinical pharmacy practitice[J]. J China Pharm (�й�ҩ��)��2009��20(16)��1278-1280.
KJELDSEN L J�� JENSEN T B�� JENSEN J J Physicians�� evaluation of clinical pharmacy revealed increased focus on quality improvement and cost savings[J]. Danish Med Bull �� 2011�� 58(5)��A4261.
MORENO G�� LONOWSKI S�� FU J�� et al . Physician experiences with clinical pharmacists in primary care teams[J]. J Am Pharm Assoc �� 2017�� 57(6)��686-691.